NEGASS home page Gilbert Sullivan pdf copies

Vol. XXIX No. 3
November-December 2004
 ~ Winter, after all, is best - Fal la! ~

Saturday, December 11 at 1:00 PM

In This Issue:

NEGASS Business

Meeting News

Performances and auditions
in NE and elsewhere











We still have a lot of members who are due to renew. If you aren't sure as to whether you are one of these, please look at your label [i.e., the label on the envelope in which your latest issue of The Trumpet Bray arrived] and check the right upper corner. On it is a letter for your donation category (for example, a "Y" for Yeomen), and an expiration date (listed as month/year). If this letter/number area is in red, your membership needs renewal. If it is marked with green, you have a membership card inside. – JANICE DALLAS


How to get there - First Parish Church, Lexington, MA)

Parker Hall at First Parish Church in Lexington dance!has been reserved for NEGASS for Saturday, December 11 from 1:00 to 4:00 PM. We will also have use of the kitchen if it is needed and the use of the fireplace. (I will provide kindling and logs.) The piano has recently been tuned.

HOW TO GET THERE: First Parish is located at 7 Harrington Road, at the other end of the town green from the Minute Man Statue in Lexington center. Harrington Road can be approached either by Massachusetts Avenue or Bedford Street. Enter the drive to the left of the church. There is a public telephone which can be answered near the space we will be using. The number is: 781-862-9771.

Everyone should enter the church at the rear where there is an elevator. Parker Hall is on the lower level. People can park behind the church; there is also on-street parking. --NANCY BURDINE

More about the party: If the weather is being snowy or icy, call Program Chair Dave Leigh at (781) 894-3009 to see if the party is still on. Carol Mahoney notes that the date is the Eve of St. Lucia, the Scandinavian Midwinter Solstice and Celebration of Light!

Some main dishes will be provided, but you are also welcome to bring a dessert, ethnic treat, appetizer or drink. If your dish needs a serving utensil, please bring one, labeled with your name. (If you please!)

Entertainment: there will probably be singing, so bring your scores. It is not yet known if there will be video equipment.


to top


[NOTE: Our reviewer arrived late, and therefore used his overactive imagination for the beginning of this event… tsw]

On October 17, I had the honor of joining a happy band of fellow NEGASSers at Marion Leeds Carroll's house in Arlington, for a sing-through of PRINCESS IDA. As a prelude to the main event, [Pure fiction! –tsw] Rebecca Burstein and Skyler Wrench delighted us with their lyricism and scholarly prowess by reciting their new "family-friendly" translation of Tennyson's THE PRINCESS (the poem upon which IDA was based) in the ancient, heathen language of Q'abat-kai. As Q'abat-kai has a known vocabulary of only twenty-seven words, and all of them are obscene, this did not take very long, and soon Tom Dawkins was at the piano, playing the Introduction.

The cast was as follows:

Princess Ida:


Marion Leeds Carroll

Lady Blanche:


Isabel Leonard

Lady Psyche:


Rebecca Burstein



Jess Raine



Jennifer Dohm



Randi Kestin



Joe Melhada

King Gama:


Sheldon Hochman

King Hildebrand:


Tony Parkes

Hilarion, Prologue:


Carl Weggel

Hilarion, Acts 1&2; Arac Prologue:


Dave Leigh

Arac, Acts 1 & 2:


Tom Dawkins



Matthew Morse



Brian Bermack



J. Donald Smith



T. Skyler Wrench



Tom Dawkins

There were some delightful improvisations thrown in, most notably Isabel, as Lady Blanche, questioning the definition of "is", and Dave's very loud high notes at the end of "Whom Thou Hast Chained" (his high C was a trifle strained, though). All in all, it was a truly enjoyable afternoon. People should perform this opera more often.


[Although We are now a Person of No Capacity, We still get to upload the Bray to the Web site, so We do get to put in Our tuppence: Dave's high C sounded splendid! - We suspect someday he may be convinced to join the ranks of tenors... mlc]

to top

Tentative Meeting Schedule, 2004 - 2005

December 11 Holiday party, Lexington
January 16 [note change of date!], 2005 Film (probably RUDDIGORE) at the Newton Free Library
March 20 [note change of date!] LMLO PINAFORE
April 17 G&S Potpourri - TRIAL / Bab Ballads/ G without S
June 5 Elections/Fantasy meeting
Next Bray Copy Deadline: Dec. 26, 2004

Next Bray Stuffing: Sunday, Jan 2, 2005, 3 pm, at the home of Janice & Ron Dallas, 63 Everett St in Arlington, MA. Email for directions:

to top

MUSINGS ON YEOMEN, by Dean Edmonds

I am impelled to write after reading Allen Cohen's interesting review of YEOMEN OF THE GUARD in the August Bray, [2003—to see the review in question, go to –tsw] in which he refers to YEOMEN (Note that it's Yeomen, plural!) as "G&S's famous tragedy." This is the first time I've seen it so called in print (and it's not just a hint in print!), although I've thought of it as such for many years. In fact, I give a bit of a talk entitled "THE YEOMEN OF THE GUARD, Gilbert-and-Sullivan's True Grand Opera," thus discounting Sullivan's grand operatic effort in IVANHOE. In it I point out that Jack Point is the only real character in the piece - a man of talent, education, and wit, who, having neither money nor birth, can only aspire to the profession of a fool.

I've often wondered if Gilbert did this on purpose. He was, after all, a rather surly curmudgeon with a bitter streak at his heart. And although in all his operas he lampoons the set professions of his time -- "the Army, the Navy, the Church, and the Stage," and, of course, the Law -- his display in YEOMEN is perhaps the bitterest of all. Why, then, in this grand-opera setting, should he have a cast of characters that outdo in shallowness even the accepted denizens of light opera? Consider Phoebe, the flibbertigibbet who can't restrain herself from revealing the plot to free Fairfax and must thus marry Wilfred, "for even brutes must marry"; Elsie, who doesn't know a good man when she sees one; Dame Carruthers, the battleaxe of the Tower; Sergeant Meryll, the military stereotype, and, worst of all, Fairfax the airhead, who must always have blonde curls and wear court regalia even when in prison. And then there's Kate. Who's Kate? Somebody the cat dragged in so that the fact that Elsie married somebody in a cell could come out. I'm amazed that Allen should even hint at the idea of Point marrying her, although of course he immediately indicates that such a denouement would ruin the whole show.

But it's also true that Gilbert, however much he was mastermind of the stage, got himself in a jam at YEOMEN's conclusion. In no other of his works (with the exception of PATIENCE, where you want nobody to be Bunthorne's bride) is a perfectly good principal left at the end with no spouse. I'm sure he was embarrassed about this and proceeded to load the whole problem on the shoulders of subsequent directors with his final stage direction, "Point falls insensible at [Elsie's] feet."

Point and Elsie

I've seen numerous productions of YEOMEN in which the director has endeavored to lend some semblance of verisimilitude to Point's dropping dead right there. After all, we have it on no less an authority than Katisha herself "that no one ever yet died of a broken heart." One attempt was a performance in which Point was portrayed as having a heart condition throughout the show, so that one was prepared for his dropping dead (in true grand-opera style) at the end. In another curious attempt, the director had the entire chorus, who were equipped with flowered lances in some sort of celebration of the Fairfax-Elsie betrothal, line up and point in unison, a la Music Hall Rockettes, at the jester's prostrate figure. A pretty silly ploy, but at least it diverted attention from the surprisingly sudden demise of the No. l character. Only once have I seen that last scene acted in a believable way, and that was years ago at a performance in New York by the old D'Oyly Carte Company which still went on tour with such greats as Darrell Fancourt and Martyn Green. Green played that finale in a manner that left no doubt that he was not just the comedian whose antics we took for granted in such roles as Ko-Ko and the Lord Chancellor but an actor of the highest order. I will never forget that performance, and the only reason why YEOMEN is not my favorite Gilbert-and-Sullivan (my actual favorites are IOLANTHE and GONDOLIERS) is that I dislike leaving the theatre in tears. Remember, after Sullivan has done his best to make a finale out of "With happiness their souls are cloyed, this is their joy day unalloyed!" there is a sudden silence as Jack Point enters, jester's regalia drooping, "food for fishes only fitted," and says, "Ye thoughtless crew, ye know not what ye do! Attend to me, and shed a tear or two. For I have a song to sing, oh ---." You know the rest, but now his trials are o'er only in death. Of course I'm in tears! It's a real grand-opera ending, perhaps finer than most, if ever there was one.

Kind regards always, --DEAN EDMONDS, JR.

[-- again - although We are now a Person of No Capacity, We have Our own opinions on this topic. So do others. Expect to see responses in the next Bray! - mlc]

to top

Looking for the reviews in this issue? Visit our review page.

Looking for the Calendar section, featuring local auditions and performances? Visit our Calendar page

INDEX TO RECENT ON-LINE BRAYS There are no links yet to the out-of-date calendar pages - but the articles are now available. Enjoy! - mlc

Note: Very old issues of The Trumpet Bray are still available in The G & S Archives.

to top

IN-PROGRESS PDF BRAY ARCHIVE We've been posting PDF versions of recent Brays on the web. What does this mean? It means that if you have a (free and easily accessible) copy of Adobe Acrobat Reader on your computer, you can print out a copy of the issue you want, looking pretty much the same as the copy you received in the mail - in case you lost your old copy, or want to give a copy to someone else. Ultimately, We hope to create a more nearly complete archive of old Brays in PDF format.



All contributions are welcome, of course - but, strictly speaking, only activities and articles relating to G&S ought to be published. (…although an occasional Yes We Know It's Not slips by when the subject relates to a promising activity presented by long-standing and active member of NEGASS.)

  1. E-mail is the best way to send things! - is the best path. (Actually, anything else will also get here, eventually...)
  2. The US Postal Service (aka "snail mail") is fine, too - send letters, preferably typed, or hand-written very clearly so that We can read and correctly reproduce names, dates, etc. - to NEGASS, PO Box 367, Arlington, MA 02476-0004.
  3. The Telephone is a very last choice: Editor T. Skyler Wrench can be reached at 617-924-5303. Note: spellings of names and specifics of dates are awfully hard to be sure of when delivered by Word of Mouth (Oricular or otherwise), and We rarely have time to phone people back to check details. Please use the phone only if you have no other choice!

 -- mlc   

to top

Visit for a list of G&S ensembles suitable for excerpt programs.

Visit for a NEGASS business card image.

* ... why We see a neurologist...


  Calendar             Officers  

PO Box 367, Arlington, MA 02476-0004

Send electronic contributions to our e-mail address:



contact current webmaster mlc for more information